EO 12391Executive OrderReagan · R Quiet signal

Executive Order 12391

Partial suspension of Federal service labor-management relations

This executive order partially suspends federal labor-management relations protections for U.S. citizen Defense Department employees working overseas (except Panama) when those protections would interfere with implementing treaties or agreements with host nations. The Secretary of Defense has final authority to resolve disputes over coverage, after consulting the Secretary of State.

No PDF available for this document.

Key directives

  • Suspend 5 U.S.C. 7105(a)(2)(D),(E),(G),(H) and 7123(b) for treaty-implementation matters
  • Suspend 5 U.S.C. 7102(2), 7114(a)(1), 7114(a)(4), 7116(a)(5), 7117(c) for proposed bargaining affecting treaties
  • Suspend 5 U.S.C. 7116(a)(7) and 7117(b) for regulations governing treaty implementation
  • Suspend 5 U.S.C. 7121(b)(3)(C) for grievances involving treaty implementation
  • Refer coverage disputes to Secretary of Defense for final decision after State Department consultation
  • Limit delegation of Defense authority to Deputy/Under/Assistant Secretaries of Defense
  • Prohibit delegation of State functions below Assistant Secretary rank

Who is ordered

Timeline

Immediate

  • Suspensions take effect upon signing for covered employees
  • Secretary of Defense dispute resolution authority activated

Near term (90d)

  • Potential disputes referred to Secretary of Defense for binding resolution

Long term

  • Ongoing limitation of collective bargaining rights for overseas DoD workforce
  • Precedent for national security-based labor rights suspensions

Risks & tensions

  • No expiration date stated — suspensions appear indefinite
  • Vague standard: 'substantially impairs' treaty implementation leaves broad discretion
  • Unilateral executive override of statutory labor protections without congressional action
  • Final and non-reviewable Secretary of Defense decisions raise due process concerns
  • Exclusion of Panama suggests diplomatic sensitivity but rationale unexplained
Executive Order 12391: Partial suspension of Federal service labor-management relations · Executive Orders