EO 12938Executive OrderClinton · D Quiet signal

Executive Order 12938

Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction

This executive order declares a national emergency to counter the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and their delivery systems. It establishes a comprehensive framework of export controls, sanctions against foreign persons and countries involved in chemical and biological weapons proliferation, and mandates multilateral diplomatic efforts led by the Secretary of State.

No PDF available for this document.

Impact dates

  1. Secretary of Commerce to promulgate rules, regulations, and amendments to regulate U.S. person activities under EAR

  2. Secretary of State to pursue early negotiations with foreign governments for comparable measures (Section 3(a))

  3. Implementation actions under Sections 4 and 5 per procedures established pursuant to EO 12851

  4. Effective date of order and revocation of EO 12735 and EO 12930

Key directives

  • Secretary of State shall cooperate in and lead multilateral nonproliferation efforts
  • Secretary of Commerce shall prohibit exports of goods, technology, or services that would assist WMD acquisition
  • Secretary of Commerce shall require validated licenses and coordinate with State and Defense
  • Secretary of Commerce shall regulate U.S. person activities to prevent WMD proliferation participation
  • Secretary of State shall pursue early negotiations for comparable foreign export controls
  • Sanctions imposed on foreign persons knowingly contributing to chemical/biological weapons efforts on or after November 16, 1990
  • U.S. government procurement ban and import prohibition on sanctioned foreign persons
  • Sanctions imposed on foreign countries using, preparing to use, or acquiring chemical/biological weapons in violation of international law
  • Eight specified sanctions against foreign countries including foreign assistance denial, multilateral bank opposition, credit denial, arms sales prohibition, export restrictions, import restrictions, and landing rights termination
  • Secretary of State and Treasury may provide exemptions for military requirements, sole source suppliers, spare parts, routine servicing, medical/humanitarian items, and pre-existing contracts

Who is ordered

Timeline

Immediate

  • Order effective immediately upon signing (November 14, 1994)
  • Revocation of Executive Orders 12735 and 12930
  • Export controls under Secretary of Commerce jurisdiction activated
  • Sanctions framework for foreign persons and countries becomes operative

Near term (90d)

  • Secretary of Commerce to promulgate rules and regulations to implement export controls
  • Secretary of State to pursue early negotiations with foreign governments for comparable measures
  • Agency implementation procedures to be established per Executive Order 12851

Long term

  • Sanctions remain until Secretary of State determines lifting is in U.S. interests
  • Ongoing multilateral coordination on nonproliferation
  • Continued evolution of Export Administration Regulations

Risks & tensions

  • Vague 'early negotiations' timeline lacks enforceable deadline
  • Broad discretionary authority ('determines,' 'deemed adequate') concentrated in Secretary of State creates uncertainty for exporters
  • Retroactive application to November 16, 1990 raises due process concerns for foreign persons
  • Exemption provisions for 'appropriate circumstances' on pre-existing contracts are vague and could undermine sanctions coherence
  • Potential tension between sanctions and humanitarian exemptions
  • Landing rights termination requires consistency with international law, creating legal friction
Executive Order 12938: Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction · Executive Orders