EO 14040Executive OrderBiden · D

Executive Order 14040

Declassification Reviews of Certain Documents Concerning the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001

This executive order mandates a phased declassification review of FBI and other agency documents related to the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, prioritizing transparency for survivors and victims' families while protecting national security. The Attorney General and relevant agency heads must complete reviews of specific records on rolling deadlines between September 11, 2021 and approximately March 2022.

Impact dates

  1. Declassification review of all other FBI investigation records on subfile subjects relevant to 9/11 or foreign government agency relationships

  2. Declassification review of PENTTBOM investigation records referencing subfile subjects

  3. Declassification review of all other previously withheld classified records from 9/11 litigation and 2021 FBI electronic communication closing subfile investigation

  4. Declassification review of April 4, 2016 FBI electronic communication from subfile investigation

Key directives

  • Attorney General and agency heads to complete declassification reviews on four specified deadlines
  • Declassification determinations must follow Executive Order 13526 standards
  • Information may remain classified only if still requires national security protection and disclosure would reasonably cause damage
  • Significant doubt about classification need requires declassification
  • Classification cannot be used to conceal law violations, inefficiency, administrative error, or embarrassment
  • Public interest in disclosure may override national security damage in discretionary determinations
  • Non-classified information must be disentangled from classified information and made publicly available
  • Reports to President and congressional intelligence committees required upon each review completion
  • Public release of declassified information required, except for confidential executive branch deliberations

Who is ordered

Timeline

Immediate

  • Declassification review of April 4, 2016 FBI electronic communication due by September 11, 2021

Near term (90d)

  • Review of all other previously withheld classified records from 9/11 litigation due by November 2, 2021 (60 days)
  • Review of 2021 FBI electronic communication closing subfile investigation due by November 2, 2021 (60 days)
  • Review of PENTTBOM investigation records referencing subfile subjects due by January 1, 2022 (120 days)

Long term

  • Review of all other FBI investigation records on subfile subjects due by March 2, 2022 (180 days)
  • Public release of declassified information
  • Reports to President and congressional intelligence committees

Risks & tensions

  • Extremely tight first deadline (8 days) for initial review may strain analytical rigor
  • Potential tension between transparency mandate and national security protections in Section 3(a)
  • Discretionary 'public interest' balancing in Section 3(b) creates uncertainty about actual disclosure volume
  • Confidential executive branch deliberations exception in Section 5 may swallow significant disclosures
  • No enforcement mechanism for non-compliance with deadlines or disclosure obligations
Executive Order 14040: Declassification Reviews of Certain Documents Concerning the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001 · Executive Orders